Researchers may have found a way to detect inklings of consciousness in comatose and vegetative patients just days after they experience a brain injury—and it appears the method may help predict which patients will rouse and recover in the months afterward.
A team of researchers in New York recorded electrical activity in the brains of unresponsive patients while giving them simple spoken commands, such as “keep opening and closing your right hand” or “wiggle your toes.” Of 104 unresponsive patients tested, 16 (15%) showed some activity. Of those 16 patients, eight of them (50%) went on to be able to follow spoken commands by the time they left the hospital. A year later, seven of them (44%) were able to function independently for at least eight hours at a time.
In contrast, only 14% of those who showed no electrical activity early on reached that level of recovery after a year. The results were published this week in the New England Journal of Medicine.
The study was small, and the authors caution that the results “require validation in larger, multi-center studies that are powered to detect differences in long-term outcomes.” But, if the findings hold up, the study could offer clinicians a way to help assess which patients may be able to emerge from a coma or vegetative state.
The study isnt the first to find that some otherwise unresponsive patients show brain activity to spoken commands that doesnt seem to get translated to behavior, that is, actually wiggling their toes, for example. Researchers call such a disconnect “cognitive-motor dissociation,” and a 2016 meta-analysis of dozens of studies have estimated that it occurs in about 14% of chronically unresponsive patients. Thats close to the prevalence that the New York team found.
The electrical activity appears to be a response to the spoken commands and, perhaps, is the brain recognizing and attempting to actually carry out the orders. But, as the New York researchers note, “whether the detected signal represents recognition or comprehension of commands is uncertain.” Researchers also remain uncertain as to whether the detected activity has any bearing on patients outcomes.
The new study tries to get at this question by following up with the patients over a year. All the work was conducted in a single intensive care unit with patients admitted between 2014 and 2017. Unresponsive patients were screened and tested in their first few days in the hospital. Researchers enrolled patients who were in a coma, in a vegetative state, or in a “minimally conscious state–minus” state, in which certain low-level behaviors are preserved. These include being able to follow moving objects with their eyes, visually fixate, and respond to pain or discomfort.
The cause of these conditions in the enrolled 104 unresponsive patients varied. Some patients had experienced cardiac arrest, while others had suffered traumatic brain injuries or hemorrhages.
The researchers used a common, relatively easy-to-use test to assess brain activity: an electroencephalogram. Also known as an EEG, it picks up electrical pulses using electrodes attached to the scalp (in this case, a standard assembly of 21 electrodes was used). EEGs are oRead More – Source